Welcome to Piesano’s Pizza of Shelter Island

(631) 749 - 9292

3 N. Ferry Road, Shelter Island, N.Y., 11964





Located on Shelter Island, Piesano's is a purveyor of comfort Italian cuisine rooted in years of tradition and experience.

Our restaurant is based on family values – from the way we treat our employees, to the comfort food we provide our customers.  

Our menus are shaped from family recipes and years of experience serving Italian cuisine on Long Island. We know Italian cuisine is one of everyone’s favorite foods, and we take pride in making our creations using fresh ingredients and the best cheeses available. Our passion is serving pizza, pasta and main courses that will make you happy.

Join us in our dining room or enjoy Piesano's from the comfort of your home — we deliver to the entire island.


Location and Hours



(631) 749-9292


3 N. Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964

HOURS | September 2019 Mon – Tue | Closed Wed – Sun | 12:00 pm - 8:00 pm

Hours subject to change, call for most recent hours.